Alaska Municipality League

AML has submitted public comment (below) on the Census Bureau’s proposed regulations governing residence criteria and demographic questions for the decennial census. We are urging the Census Bureau to reconsider the proposed rule and conduct greater analysis and consultation before changing census methodologies.

Learn more about the proposed changes.

Submit Public Comment by October 13.

 

AML represents Alaska’s municipal governments, which rely extensively on Census data for planning, infrastructure, public safety, housing, transportation, economic development, grant applications, and federal and state funding. AML urges the Census Bureau to reconsider the proposed rule and conduct greater analysis and consultation before changing census methodologies.
 
The decennial census must accurately describe the communities that state, local, and Tribal governments govern and serve. A methodology that produces population counts materially different from the population actually residing in and relying on a community risks reducing the usefulness of Census data for governmental decision-making.
 
Residence criteria must reflect Alaska realities. The proposed rule would define usual residence based on where a person has “lawfully spent the greatest number of days” between January 3 and April 1, with tax records identified as evidence.
 
This approach is poorly suited to Alaska, where residents may spend extended periods away from home for medical care, employment, education, military service, family needs, subsistence activities, or other reasons without abandoning their permanent residence. A January-through-March snapshot is also unrepresentative in a state where mobility and residency patterns vary seasonally.
 
The Census Bureau has long recognized Alaska’s unique enumeration needs through Remote Alaska and other in-person operations. AML recommends retaining the established concept of usual residence; ensuring temporary absences do not shift residence away from a person’s permanent home; conducting Alaska-specific testing of revised criteria; and consulting directly with municipalities and Tribal governments.
 
Administrative records should supplement, not replace, local enumeration. Alaska includes communities without conventional street addressing, households that rely on post office boxes, residents with limited broadband access, and people whose mailing, employment, health care, or tax records may point to a regional hub rather than their actual home. Administrative data should support verification and burden reduction, not supersede information from residents, municipalities, Tribes, or trained local enumerators.
 
Local governments also need a complete count of the people they serve. Municipal responsibilities for roads, emergency response, utilities, public safety, libraries, planning, and other services do not depend on immigration classification. If the Bureau uses a narrower population definition for apportionment, it should still preserve and publish a complete resident population count at equivalent geographic detail and explain which population measure will be used in future Census products.
 
AML is also concerned about eliminating race and ethnicity questions from the decennial census. Reliable small-area demographic data are especially important in Alaska, where Alaska Native people comprise substantial shares of many communities. The American Community Survey is valuable but is not equivalent to a complete enumeration, particularly in small communities where sample sizes and margins of error limit usefulness. Race and ethnicity questions should be retained unless an alternative is shown, through transparent testing and consultation, to provide equal or better accuracy, geographic detail, timeliness, and continuity, including in rural Alaska and Alaska Native communities.
 
Finally, AML disagrees that the proposal lacks substantial federalism implications. Census data influence planning, grant competitiveness, funding formulas, infrastructure design, demographic projections, and decisions by other levels of government. In communities of only a few hundred residents, even small enumeration errors can materially alter per-capita statistics and how local needs are understood.
Before finalizing the rule, the Bureau should more fully assess impacts on state, local, and Tribal governments, including funding formulas, population estimates, small-area demographic data, comparability with prior censuses, rural and remote communities, nontraditional addressing systems, Alaska Native villages, and communities with significant seasonal population movement.
 
AML supports efforts to improve accuracy, protect privacy, reduce unnecessary burden, and responsibly use new data sources. Those goals should not come at the expense of the census’s usefulness to the governments and communities that depend on it. AML therefore encourages the Bureau to reconsider the proposed residence and demographic restrictions, preserve a comprehensive count of residents and reliable small-area demographic data, conduct Alaska-specific testing, and engage in consultation before adopting changes of this magnitude.